The martian is one of those scifi films that appears to be highlytechnical and factual to a regular person, but the flaws in its treatment of science would make a real nasa engineer roll their eyes. Martian opens everywhere on friday, october 2, and it has amassed a huge fan following partly thanks to the books scientific accuracy. The martian is a love letter to science, but what does science think of the martian. Radioactive decay is a useful tool for nasas curiosity mars rover, exploring the martian surface right now. The film is based on the novel by andy weir, pictured here at nasa, who pleased science nerds everywhere with the book s detailed. This is where the martian book diverges so strongly. The martian is a technically accurate scifi, so tons of research and constant doublechecking of math had to be done. The martian might be the most realistic space movie ever. Im going to have to science the shit out of this, says astronaut mark watney, played. A pointbypoint breakdown of the new scifi film with the johnson space center. The martian by andy weir crown, 2014 hardcover, 384 pp. Mixing solid science with a healthy dose of fiction, it seems that weir and the martian have done just that. Although mars does get dust storms, the atmospheric pressure is so low that the wind is negligible, although the dust itself can be harmful.
Home study guides the martian chapters summary and analysis the martian. A few days ago i went to see the martian, starring matt damon and directed by ridley scott. The payoff is a survival story so realistic, itll make you wonder, could a stranded astronaut really survive on mars. Behind the science of the martian astronomy magazine. Get the latest updates on nasa missions, watch nasa tv live, and learn about our quest to reveal the unknown and benefit all humankind. The martian, starring matt damon, was quite scientifically accurate. After a couple days on mars, a giant dust storm disrupts the astronauts mission and forces an abort. And was a real page turner, i think i probably read it all the way through in one go until i finished it. That pretty much sums up the tone in ridley scotts new. The martian is entertaining science fiction rooted in. The science behind the martian and its partnership with nasa. In fact, a few of the characters, including watney, are constantly riffing and injecting the martian with wit and humor that keep the novel from becoming a dry, plodding yawner.
The martian, a science fiction film based on the novel by andy weir, might be the most realistic space exploration movie ever made. In 2011, author andy weir selfpublished a novel called the martian. Robert walkers answer to how realistic is the book the martian. Science news was founded in 1921 as an independent, nonprofit source of accurate information on the latest news of science. To write the martian, firsttime novelist andy weir had to study orbital mechanics, astronomy, and the history of manned spaceflight.
Although the noun martian can describe any organism from mars, these and later works typically imagine martians as a humanoid monoculture. In this weekends box office hit, matt damon plays an astronaut stranded on mars after his crew is hit by a sandstorm. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Weir pleased science nerds everywhere with the book s detailed mathematical calculations and scientific accuracy. Science versus fiction in the martian what the film gets right and wrong about space and mars. Lets get the big one out of the way nice and early. Growing potatoes on mars can be feasible as the basic mineral content of the soil is adequate, the shelter shown in the movie is quite realistic too. The book was the first in burroughs barsoom series. The martian is a 2011 science fiction novel written by andy weir. Now, the new york times bestseller is about to put nasas red planet plans in the limelight. T here are a few hard truths you can learn from both the book and soontobereleased film the martian.
There are a few hard truths you can learn from both the book and soontobe released film the martian. The martian scored well at the box office and we agree that its well deserved. The martian may not be completely scientifically accurate but that is certainly not a problem. How accurate is the novel the martian by andy weir in terms of science and survival on. This scifi chart topper has converted thousands of mathandsciencefearing luddites into scifiand just plain scienceenthusiasts. It also stars jessica chastain, jeff daniels, kristen. So overall, how does the scientific accuracy of the martian compare to other scifi films. The martian is a 2015 science fiction film directed by ridley scott and starring matt damon. However, there were also a few inaccuracies the martian, an american space thriller starring matt damon, was released in. Andy weir, who wrote the book the film is based on, is a longtime.
That is, the novel is an example of hard or realist science fiction, in. There are a few hard truths you can learn from both the book and soontobereleased film the martian. Does the martian accurately represent all of its prominent scientific. And whilst i appreciated them, even found them amusing, this. Tougher than duct tape, more frightening than the martian wasteland, and funkier than disco, the martian is one of the most exciting science fiction novels of recent years. Crown publishing purchased the rights and rereleased it in 2014. In fact, the martian insists on the strictest of realistic, current scientific accuracy in its story. When andy weir first began publishing the martian on his website, he had little inkling that it would become one of the years bestknown, most celebrated science fiction novels, or a bestseller. The martians science is the metaphorical white purity. Gravity, too, is an achilles heel of the films scientific accuracy. Disagree in the case of this book i havent yet seen the film though i hope to the main theme is the ingenuity of humans in using science to. How accurate is the novel the martian by andy weir in terms of. The martian like other acclaimed novels is a work of fiction even if it is so engaging that one can actually relate to all the stuff that happens to mark wattney on mars.
Every page may be riddled with science solid, hard science but it is presented in a way that is anything but boring or beyond the reach of a common reader. The martian is entertaining science fiction rooted in fact. A perfect balance of scientific accuracy and gripping fiction. The scifi blockbuster both obeys and breaks the rules of science. The latest red planet movie, the martian, is based on the novel that andy weir wrote in his spare time and originally self published. First, it was a really gripping story, i greatly enjoyed it, and had enough hard science to be very satisfying. How the martian became a science love story the movie about a stranded astronaut is being hailed for its scientific realism. The amount of space travel and scifi movies produced every year suggests that audiences have a natural curiosity for the subject matter. Websters english dictionary defines hard science fiction as being characterized by an emphasis on scientific accuracy or technical detail or both just kidding its wikipedia. It is an amazing film from ridley scott and highly entertaining.
The martian is hitting cinemas right about now, and already it is being heralded as one of the most scientifically accurate sci. The upcoming film the martian is making a huge splash for both scientists and science fans, but how scientifically accurate is it. The film depicts an astronauts lone struggle to survive on mars after being left behind, and efforts to rescue him and bring him home to earth. Dust storms certainly do occur on mars, they get winds in excess of 100 mph 160 kmh, but a 100 mph. This is the only thing i noticed that was completely impossible, as opposed to improbable or suboptimal. Martian, in this sense, is more like the word human than the word earthling. The martian chapters summary and analysis gradesaver. Selfproclaimed science geek andy weir never thought the martian would be published. The martian, a novel by andy weir, served as the screenplay adapted by drew goddard. Of the 4 the one that treats scientific accuracy the best is 2001 a space odyssey and that ends with a space baby. The book and is carried on the witticisms and banter of main character mark watney, the titular martian, and are jampacked with pop culture references, sciencey bits, and oneline zingers. Its the only film green has worked on, but its certainly the most accurate one about mars, he said. The story follows an american astronaut, mark watney, as he becomes stranded alone on mars in the year 2035 and must improvise in order to survive.
It has the very rare combination of a good, original story, interestingly real characters and fascinating technical accuracyreads like macgyver meets mysterious island. How accurate is the novel the martian by andy weir in. In the martian, science itself becomes an action hero how andy weir and his book. A perfect balance of scientific accuracy and gripping. Heres the real science behind the martian marketwatch. Space experts have challenged the accuracy of a science fiction film starring matt damon that depicts life on mars for a stranded astronaut, claiming the movie is tainted by a few space oddities.
Explain how the science in the martian is true to life. The dust storm that sets everything in motion at the start of the movie is not accurate. Space experts challenge accuracy of the martian film. The martian atmosphere is only 1% as thick as earths, so a mars wind of.
But the book seemed pretty accurate, with good science content. So, basically scifi that would satisfy comic book guy from the simpsons. Not only was the science in the source novel, about an. And were not just saying that because we heart this page turner and its. Its time for a report card on whats deadon accurate, where the facts are fudged, and whats plausible. As a former researcher on the martian atmosphere and as a science fiction movie buff, i can attest that some martian movies are complete stinkers, among them the last days on mars 20. The book was first available in chunks on weirs blog, but after fans. Astronaut mark watney is a botanist and mechanical engineer on the american ares 3 mission to mars, following two successful ares missions that have been met first with earthly excitement, then mostly indifference. The martian is a scifi hit but where do they separate the science from fiction. Im going to have to science the shit out of this, says astronaut mark watney, played by matt damon, after being stranded on mars. The only other inaccuracy i noticed was the following. More importantly none of those 5 attempt to talk science. Andy weir on his followup to the martian, and using.
937 840 105 644 660 1225 236 764 1135 841 506 527 1096 314 353 586 551 321 831 788 117 83 365 1302 954 1484 1394 385 1071 1485 582 577 454 19 1360 726 338 48 195 167